Contact Siegel
6 West 48th Street
9th Floor
New York, NY 10036
Contact by phone:
New York: (212) 753-6421
Dallas: (214) 754-5991

Sale 1225 — Civil War Postal History, featuring the 'Ambassador' Collection

Sale Date — Wednesday, 9 September, 2020

Category — Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)

Lot
Symbol
Photo/Description
Cat./Est. Value
Realized
109
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 109, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Mount Lebanon La., 5c Red Brown (60X1), Mount Lebanon La., 5c Red Brown (60X1)Mount Lebanon La., 5c Red Brown (60X1). Fine impression that shows all of the lettering and reveals the wood grain of the printing block, neatly cancelled with small pen stroke, affixed upside down on bright white cover to "Mr. D. Ripley, care Adol. Hamilton Esq., New Orleans, La." with printed corner card for "C. G. Thurmond, Dealer in Staples & Fancy Dry Goods, Hardware, Groceries, &c., &c., Mt. Lebanon, La.", stamp has huge margins cleanly cut at top and bottom and roughly separated at sides (causing a tiny tear), cover opened roughly at left, which effectively ties the stamp, a piece of backing paper affixed behind left edge of cover purely for cosmetic purposes

VERY FINE. THE FAMOUS AND UNIQUE POSTMASTER'S PROVISIONAL OF MOUNT LEBANON, LOUISIANA. THIS REMARKABLE STAMP IS A MIRROR IMAGE OF THE INTENDED DESIGN, WHICH WAS CREATED BY HAMMERING PRINTER'S TYPE INTO A WOOD BLOCK. THE MOUNT LEBANON HAS BEEN DISPLAYED AMONG THE "ARISTOCRATS OF PHILATELY" AT INTERPHIL '76, AMERIPEX '86, ANPHILEX '96 AND STAMP SHOW-NY 2016. IT IS WIDELY REGARDED AS THE MOST VALUABLE STAMP IN CONFEDERATE PHILATELY.

Mount Lebanon was settled in 1847 by immigrants from South Carolina. The village is located in Bienville Parish, which was established in 1848 and named for Jean Baptiste Sieur de Bienville, colonizer of Louisiana and founder of the city of New Orleans. It lies in northern Louisiana, approximately 400 miles distance from New Orleans. Mount Lebanon was the site of the first Baptist church in North Louisiana, and the Baptist Convention founded Mount Lebanon University in 1855. During the Civil War, the school was closed and turned into a hospital -- it moved to Pineville after the war and was re-named Louisiana College.

According to an account by L. B. Dabney, published in the Southern Philatelist (May 1929) and reprinted in the Crown book (p. 238), the Mount Lebanon postmaster during the war (1859-1865) was W. F. Wells, who was publisher of the Louisiana Baptist newspaper. According to citizens of Mount Lebanon who were interviewed by Dabney for his 1929 article, the provisional stamps were printed by Wells and used briefly in June 1861. Mount Lebanon had a wartime population of less than 1,000, and it is unlikely that the stamp saw widespread use.

Apart from its extreme rarity, the Mount Lebanon provisional stamp is believed to be the sole example of a mirror-image stamp in all of philately. The stamp was printed from a piece of wood with a relatively smooth surface. Lines were incised into the wood and strips were removed to create the borders surrounding each stamp. Horizontal and vertical ruled lines were added within the borders of each subject, and a circle was cut into the center. At this point the "engraver" took printer's type and hammered the letters spelling "Mt. Lebanon La." around the circle, and the numeral "5" was impressed into the center. The enlarged photo shown here in upright position clearly shows the effect of this process -- the printed stamp is a mirror image of the right-reading wood engraving. As anyone familiar with printing knows, the plate used to print an image must mirror the intended design. This principle of typography was missed or ignored by the creator of the Mount Lebanon provisional.

The single known example shows parts of three adjoining subjects at left, at the extreme bottom-left corner, and at bottom. There is additional printing to the right of the primary impression, which we think is a second impression. Judging from the size, shape and line breaks of this second impression, this might be the bottom of the woodblock, turned 90 degrees. Such work-and-turn printing is found on other provisionals (Memphis 5c, for example). All of this is purely hypothetical, and we encourage others to develop a better explanation.

The Mount Lebanon cover was part of the Ferrary collection sold at auction in Paris in 1925-1927. It next appeared in the Alfred H. Caspary sale held by H. R. Harmer in 1956, where A. Earl Weatherly acquired it for his collection. At the invitation of Weatherly in 1963, Charles and Lucy Kilbourne acquired a number of important provisional rarities by private sale, including the Mount Lebanon. Most of the Kilbourne Confederate Postmasters' Provisionals collection was sold by Siegel in 1999 (Sale 815, the Mount Lebanon was lot 93 and appeared on the front cover). The successful bidder in the Kilbourne sale was William H. Gross, who paid $385,000 -- a world record price for any Confederate philatelic item. The Gross Confederate collection was sold by Charles F. Shreve in 2009 (Spink-Shreves sale, Nov. 19, 2009, the Mount Lebanon was lot 31 and appeared on the front cover). At the Gross sale the successful bidder was the Hon. J. William Middendorf II. It has been shown in the Aristocrats of Philately display, alongside major philatelic rarities of the world, at Interphil 1976, Ameripex 1986, Anphilex 1996 and World Stamp Show-NY 2016.

Ex Ferrary, Caspary, Weatherly, Kilbourne and Gross.

255,000
0
110
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 110, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Mount Lebanon La. May 20 (1861), Mount Lebanon La. May 20 (1861)Mount Lebanon La. May 20 (1861). Circular datestamp struck over indicia of U.S. 3c Red on Buff, Star Die entire (U27) to New Orleans La., Very Fine Confederate use of U.S. postage and a nice tie-in with the unique Postmaster's Provisional offered in lot 109, ex Kimmel

E. 300-400
300
Back to Top
111
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 111, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Mount Lebanon La. Feb. 4 (1862), Mount Lebanon La. Feb. 4 (1862)Mount Lebanon La. Feb. 4 (1862). Bold strike of circular datestamp with date in manuscript, clear strike of "Paid 5" in circle handstamp (modified "3") on yellow cover to New Orleans, Carroll Hoy & Co. correspondence with the usual small staple holes, charge box notation at top, Extremely Fine, ex Weatherly, Freeland, Weill Brothers' Stock and Kilbourne, an excellent companion to the unique Mount Lebanon Postmaster's Provisional offered in lot 109

E. 400-500
375
Back to Top
112
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 112, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Mobile Ala., 5c Blue (58X2), Mobile Ala., 5c Blue (58X2)Mobile Ala., 5c Blue (58X2). Vertical pair, ample margins to just touched at upper right, tied by Mobile Ala. double-circle datestamp with indistinct date on black-bordered mourning cover to Clarksville Ga., top stamp with some minor wrinkles and cover with couple edge tears, still Very Fine, a scarce use of a pair on a mourning cover, accompanied by a second No. 58X2 on about half a cover with pre-printed address to Okolona Miss., stamp with small faults, otherwise Fine, Scott value for the pair on cover is $2,000.00

E. 500-750
1,000
Back to Top
113
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 113, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 5c Deep Carmine (61X2), Nashville Tenn., 5c Deep Carmine (61X2)Nashville Tenn., 5c Deep Carmine (61X2). Beautiful dark shade, large margins three sides including traces of adjoining stamps at bottom and left, clear to touched at right, tied by blue "Nashville Ten. Oct. 27, 1861" circular datestamp on United States 3c Red Nesbitt cut square, Very Fine, a striking combination, ex Pegram, with 2007 C.S.A. certificate as Carmine, Scott value as used off-cover

650
600
Back to Top
114
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 114, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 5c Brick Red (61X3), Nashville Tenn., 5c Brick Red (61X3)Nashville Tenn., 5c Brick Red (61X3). Huge margins to touching bottom frameline, lovely shade, bold strike of blue "Nashville Ten. Aug. 7, 1861" circular datestamp with year inverted, fresh and Fine, ex Dr. Brandon, with 2014 P.F. certificate

700
800
Back to Top
115
ogbl
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 115, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown, Tete-Beche Block (61X5a), Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown, Tete-Beche Block (61X5a)Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown, Tete-Beche Block (61X5a). Block of twelve containing three vertical tete-beche pairs and six normal stamps at top and bottom, consisting of two full stereotype groups of six units, both Positions 1-3/4-6, the work and turn printing method resulting in foot-to-foot teche-beche pairs -- Positions 4 over 6, 5 over 5 and 6 over 4 -- original gum, full margins to touched, right vertical row with reinforced creases, three positions with small tears and creases -- none of these minor flaws detract from the choice appearance of this block

THE FINER OF ONLY TWO RECORDED TETE-BECHE BLOCKS OF 12 OF THE NASHVILLE 5-CENT VIOLET BROWN PROVISIONAL. A SPECTACULAR CONFEDERATE STATES RARITY AND THE LARGEST KNOWN MULTIPLE OF ANY NASHVILLE PROVISIONAL.

Peter Powell's study of the 5c Nashville (“Plating the Nashville Provisional”, Confederate Philatelist, January-March 2008) sought to correct the long-held belief that the Nashville Provisionals were printed from plates of ten. Powell concluded that stereotype groups of six units, three wide by two tall, were used to build up the Nashville printing plates. Based on plate flaws unique to specific positions, Powell also concluded that the plate size was no less than 18 subjects, made from at least three six-unit stereotype groups, and that more than one plate was made. The tete-beche arrangement in printed sheets occurred when one impression of six was made, then the sheet was turned 180 degrees ("work and turn"), and a second impression was made.

This block of twelve of the Nashville 5c Violet Brown Provisional, which is the finer of only two recorded, contains two stereotype groups of six printed foot-to-foot, yielding three tete-beche pairs. The legendary Caspary collection contained both of the recorded blocks of twelve (lots 313-314). The other block is described as being defective and with a corner repair.

Ex Caspary, Boker and Haub. With 2016 P.F. certificate. Scott value as three tete-beche pairs and six singles

(View PDF of Highlights and certificate(s) of this lot)

22,500
10,000
Back to Top
116
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 116, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown (61X5), Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown (61X5)Nashville Tenn., 5c Violet Brown (61X5). Large margins to just touched at top, wonderful rich color, tied by blue "Nashville Ten. Dec. 25, 1861" circular datestamp used on Christmas day on cover to Shelbyville Tenn., addressee's name crossed out, Very Fine, signed "Dietz" on reverse

4,250
650
Back to Top
117
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 117, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6), Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6). Ample margins to just touching, deep shade, cancelled by blue "The Southern Express Co. Nashville" oval datestamp, deep rich color, tiny tear at top right not mentioned on accompanying certificates

VERY FINE APPEARANCE. THIS IS THE ONLY RECORDED 10-CENT NASHVILLE PROVISIONAL CANCELLED BY THE "SOUTHERN EXPRESS CO. NASHVILLE" OVAL DATESTAMP. A GREAT RARITY.

Only approximately 25 are known with any cancel, most of which are faulty. While the strike of the handstamp is fairly light, the letters "SOUT" are clearly visible below the rim of the cancel. The recently discovered 5c Carmine (61X2) on cover with "The Southern Express Co. Nashville" oval, which was sold in 2010 by Schuyler Rumsey Auctions, is proof that this marking existed and was used on Nashville adhesive provisionals.

Ex Dr. Graves ("Argentum"). With 2004 P.F. certificate declining opinion on the cancellation (issued prior to the discovery of the full cancel on the 61X2 cover). With 2010 C.S.A. certificate confirming the Southern Express Co. marking. Scott value with no premium for the cancel

7,500
0
Back to Top
118
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 118, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6), Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6). Three ample to full margins, just into frameline at bottom, rich color, cancelled by Adams Express Company blue oval datestamp, couple tiny margin thins at top

FINE APPEARING EXAMPLE OF THE 10-CENT NASHVILLE PROVISIONAL WITH AN EXPRESS COMPANY CANCEL.

Only approximately 25 are known with any cancel, most of which are faulty. This stamp paid the Confederate postage on a cover carried across the lines by Adams Express Company. Only three full express covers are recorded with the Nashville 10c adhesive provisional, all dated at Nashville on August 1.

Ex Wishnietsky. Scott value as the most typical cancel

7,500
0
Back to Top
119
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 119, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6), Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6)Nashville Tenn., 10c Green (61X6). Huge margins at top and right, just in at sections of bottom and left, beautiful intense color, cancelled on bottom right corner by blue Nashville datestamp

FINE. A RARE SOUND AND LIGHTLY CANCELLED EXAMPLE OF THE 10-CENT NASHVILLE PROVISIONAL.

Only approximately 25 examples of the 10c Nashville are known, most of which are faulty. This sound example is very much the exception to that rule.

Ex Fekete. With 1986 P.F. certificate

7,500
1,600
Back to Top
120
og
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 120, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)New Orleans La., 2c Blue (62X1), New Orleans La., 2c Blue (62X1)New Orleans La., 2c Blue (62X1). Positions 27/35, vertical pair, large margins with traces of adjoining stamps at left and part three-line imprint at bottom, just clear at top right, original gum, tiny h.r., horizontal creases thru top stamp, between stamps and in margin where it ends in small paper breaks

VERY FINE APPEARANCE. ONE OF ONLY TWO EXAMPLES OF THE 2-CENT BLUE NEW ORLEANS PROVISIONAL WITH BOTTOM IMPRINT AND THE ONLY PAIR.

This and an unused single are the only two recorded examples of the 2c Blue with bottom imprint.

Ex Caspary, Dr. Skinner, "D.K." collection, Pegram and Felton. With 2001 P.F. certificate

E. 2,000-3,000
1,800
Back to Top
121
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 121, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)New Orleans La., 5c Brown, British Papermaker's Embossed Coat of Arms (62X3 var), New Orleans La., 5c Brown, British Papermaker's Embossed Coat of Arms (62X3 var)New Orleans La., 5c Brown, British Papermaker's Embossed Coat of Arms (62X3 var). Full even margins, cancelled by "PAID" and part of New Orleans circular datestamp

VERY FINE. THIS IS THE ONLY RECORDED EXAMPLE OF A NEW ORLEANS PROVISIONAL WITH THE BRITISH PAPERMAKER'S EMBOSSED SEAL.

Ex Knapp, Brown, "D.K." collection and Pegram

E. 1,500-2,000
1,000
Back to Top
122
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 122, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)New Orleans La., 5c Brown on White (62X3), New Orleans La., 5c Brown on White (62X3)New Orleans La., 5c Brown on White (62X3). Large margins, detailed impression, neat strike of "PAID" handstamp cancel, Extremely Fine Gem, with 2015 P.S.E. certificate (XF-Superb 95; unpriced in SMQ)

200
350
Back to Top
123
 
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 123, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4), New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4)New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4). Large margins all around, lovely color on deeply blued paper, neat strike of "PAID" handstamp cancel, Extremely Fine Gem, with 1997 P.F. and 2015 P.S.E. certificates (XF-Superb 95; unpriced in SMQ)

200
425
Back to Top
124
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 124, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4), New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4)New Orleans La., 5c Red Brown on Bluish (62X4). Horizontal pair, large margins to just in at bottom of right stamp, neat "PAID" cancels, tied by "New Orleans La. 22 Sep." (1861) circular datestamp on cover with gray-black "The South", Soldier, Flag and Tents with 11 Stars Patriotic Medallion (TF-6), addressed to Col. Henry Marshall at Columbia S.C., expertly repaired opening tears along top thru design and sealed slit below stamps at right

EXTREMELY FINE APPEARANCE. THIS IS THE ONLY RECORDED EXAMPLE OF "THE SOUTH" MEDALLION PATRIOTIC DESIGN -- USED WITH A PAIR OF NEW ORLEANS POSTMASTER'S PROVISIONALS, IT IS A TRULY REMARKABLE COVER.

Ex Richey, Grant, Dukeshire, Everett and Kilbourne. Illustrated in Wishnietsky book on p. 118. With 1990 P.F. certificate

E. 4,000-5,000
2,300
Back to Top
125
c
Sale Number 1225, Lot Number 125, Postmasters' Provisionals (Mt. Lebanon thru New Orleans)Steamer Empire Parish 5cts. Paid, Steamer Empire Parish 5cts. PaidSteamer Empire Parish 5cts. Paid. Bold strike of oval name-of-boat handstamp with rate in manuscript over place where U.S. half-dime was affixed and removed by steamboat operator, clear "PD 5 CTS/N.O.P.O." two-line provisional handstamp with "New Orleans La. 19 Nov." (1861) circular datestamp on buff cover to Kirkwood Miss., few inconsequential edge tears at bottom

VERY FINE. A RARE AND OUTSTANDING COMBINATION OF THE EMPIRE PARISH MISSISSIPPI RIVER PACKET BOAT HANDSTAMP AND THE NEW ORLEANS PROVISIONAL HANDSTAMP.

This cover was posted on the Steamer Empire Parish with a U.S. half-dime attached with a red wax seal. The boat captain or purser removed the coin and struck the "STEAMER EMPIRE PARISH" oval and wrote "5 cts. paid" over the spot where the coin had been attached. On arrival at New Orleans it was handstamped with the "PD 5 CTS/N.O.P.O." marking over the same spot.

Accompanied by 1860 half-dime to represent what may have been included with the cover to pay postage in New Orleans. Ex Dr. Brandon. With 2014 P.F. certificate

E. 3,000-4,000
3,750
Back to Top
Copyright 2020. All rights reserved by Siegel Auction Galleries Inc. Information and images may be used with credit to Siegel Auction Galleries or siegelauctions.com subject to guidelines and restrictions.
Website Terms of Use and Privacy Policy