Contact Siegel
6 West 48th Street
9th Floor
New York, NY 10036
Contact by phone:
New York: (212) 753-6421
Dallas: (214) 754-5991

Sale 1096 — The Robert R. Hall Collection of Outstanding United States Stamps

Sale Date — Tuesday-Thursday, 28-30 April, 2015

Category — 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)

Lot
Symbol
Photo/Description
Cat./Est. Value
Realized
552
nh
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 552, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)4c Brown, Imperforate, Schermack Ty. III (314A). Mint N.H, 4c Brown, Imperforate, Schermack Ty. III (314A). Mint N.H4c Brown, Imperforate, Schermack Ty. III (314A). Mint N.H., rich color and proof-like impression, choice centering with full Schermack perforations clear of design, tiny faint brownish speck in gum at left (noted here purely for accuracy and not even mentioned when the pair from which this stamp was cut was certified)

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. THIS IS THE ONLY RECORDED MINT NEVER-HINGED SINGLE OF THE RARE 4-CENT 1908 IMPERFORATE. ONLY TWO MINT NEVER-HINGED EXAMPLES OF THIS GREAT RARITY ARE KNOWN, AND ONLY FOUR PAIRS, TWO LINE PAIRS AND NINE SINGLES ARE KNOWN IN UNUSED CONDITION.

Our census of unused Scott 314A, available at http://www.siegelauctions.com/enc/census/314A.pdf , records four pairs, two guide line pairs and nine singles, for a total of 21 unused stamps. One of the singles is in the Miller Collection at The New York Public Library. Our census also contains 44 used examples, including three strips of three (one on cover), three singles on separate covers, and 32 single used copies.

With the rising popularity of vending and affixing machines, the Bureau of Engraving and Printing received numerous requests from manufactures for supplies of imperforate stamps, which could then be privately perforated to conform to each firm's machine. In May 1908, a supply of 25 sheets (400 stamps per sheet) of the 4c 1902 Issue, without perforations, was delivered to the Schermack Mailing Machine Co. in Detroit. The entire supply was cut into coils with Schermack Type III perforations, designed for the firm's patented affixing machine and delivered to the Winfield Printing Co. for use on mass mailings of advertising material. Approximately 6,000 were used on a mailing for Hamilton Carhartt Manufacturer, and almost all of the 4,000 balance were used on a mailing for Burroughs Adding Machine Co.

All of the Scott 314A stamps that exist in unused condition originate from a local Detroit stamp collector, Karl Koslowski, who was the only one to purchase some of the 4c Imperforates, either from the Winfield Printing Company or from the Schermack firm. His earliest account of the event appeared two years later in the Philadelphia Stamp News, and is considered to be the most reliable of several conflicting stories told by Koslowski (and interpreted by others) at later dates. In the 1910 article, Koslowski explains that he purchased 50 stamps and expected to be able to buy more, but the supply was destroyed when he returned. We can account for 32 of the 50 stamps Koslowski claims he acquired. There are 21 unused stamps currently in our census, all of which must have come from him, and he used at least 11 stamps on mail to friends, including the strip of three on a Koslowski cover, two used strips of three off cover (the mass mailings were all singles) and two singles on separate Koslowski covers. The earliest known cover is dated at Detroit on May 27, 1908, from Koslowski to a friend in Austria, and the latest is dated April 8, 1909, which was mailed to him using a sheet-margin single from Sicklerville, New Jersey. Apart from the stamps Koslowski used, there is one recorded commercial cover (June 2, 1908) and approximately 32 used single stamps, most of which were probably removed from the mass-mailing covers.

The two recorded Mint N.H. examples of Scott 314A come from the ex-Lilly strip of five, which was cut into two pairs and one single by Jack E. Molesworth after it appeared in the 1985 Rarities sale. We shall refer to the stamps in that strip as #'s 1-5. Stamp #1 was cut as a single and is described in the 1985 Rarities sale as having slight margin thinning (it is hinged, although we erroneously reported it as Mint N.H. in our earlier census report). The pair comprising #2-3 was sold as part of the Zoellner collection in 1998, and soon after was divided into the Mint N.H. single (#2, the stamp offered here) and hinged single (#3, ex Whitman). The pair comprising #4-5 was also ex Whitman. The left stamp in this pair (#4) is Mint N.H., one of two known in that condition. The pair with one stamp Mint N.H. realized $400,000 hammer in our 2009 Whitman sale.

Ex Koslowski, Schmalzreidt, Col. Edward H. R. Green, Lilly and B. D. Phillips as part of a strip of five. Ex "Connoisseur" (McNall) and Zoellner as a pair. The Zoellner pair was divided shortly after our 1998 auction, and this Mint N.H. stamp was sold to Mr. Hall. With copy of 1998 P.F. certificate for pair, which states "the left stamp never hinged and the right stamp previously hinged"

200,000
200,000
553
nh
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 553, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)5c Blue, Imperforate (315), 5c Blue, Imperforate (315)5c Blue, Imperforate (315). Mint N.H., large even margins all around, Extremely Fine

600
800
Back to Top
554
nh
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 554, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)5c Blue, Imperforate (315), 5c Blue, Imperforate (315)5c Blue, Imperforate (315). Horizontal pair, slight gum disturbance at top from hinge removal, large margins, Extremely Fine

675
500
Back to Top
555
ogbl
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 555, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)5c Blue, Imperforate (315), 5c Blue, Imperforate (315)5c Blue, Imperforate (315). Block of four, bottom stamps Mint N.H., top stamps lightly hinged, large margins, intense color, Very Fine and choice, with 1990 P.F. certificate, Scott Retail as two pairs

1,975
1,200
Back to Top
556
nhbl
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 556, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)5c Blue, Imperforate (315), 5c Blue, Imperforate (315)5c Blue, Imperforate (315). Mint N.H. right imprint and plate no. 4073 block of six, large margins, deep rich color, natural inclusion in selvage

EXTREMELY FINE MINT NEVER-HINGED PLATE BLOCK OF THE 5-CENT 1908 IMPERFORATE ISSUE.

Unlike many examples of this issue, this plate block is bright and fresh, and the gum shows none of the toning that frequently plagues multiples.

4,750
2,700
Back to Top
557
og
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 557, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)1c Blue Green, Coil (316), 1c Blue Green, Coil (316)1c Blue Green, Coil (316). Pair, lightly hinged, rich color, well-centered for this difficult issue, few perf separations expertly reinforced

VERY FINE AND CHOICE PAIR OF THE RARE 1908 ONE-CENT VERTICAL COIL, SCOTT 316. OUR CENSUS RECORDS ONLY TWELVE PAIRS AND ONE SINGLE. THIS IS ONE OF THE FINEST PAIRS IN EXISTENCE.

According to Johl, these first government coils were an experiment, and collectors and dealers were generally unaware of their existence. Regular sheets of 400 were printed and then perforated in only one direction. They were then cut into strips of 20. The strips were then pasted together to form rolls.

It is unknown exactly how many of these experimental coils were produced (one paste-up pair is known). They were superseded less than a year later by the Washington-Franklin issue coils, the first of which were issued on December 29, 1908.

Our census of Scott 316, which is available at our website at http://siegelauctions.com/enc/census/316.pdf records nine pairs, three line pairs (one of which is rejoined) and an unused single, for a total of 25 stamps. None are known used.

Census No. 316-OG-PR-01. Ex Engel as part of a strip of three, ex "Connoisseur" (McNall) and Zoellner as a pair. With 1961 P.F. certificate as the strip and 1992 P.F. certificate as a pair

240,000
310,000
Back to Top
558
nh
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 558, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)5c Blue, Coil (317), 5c Blue, Coil (317)5c Blue, Coil (317). Pair with paste-up tab at bottom, top stamp Mint N.H., intense shade and impression on crisp paper, nicely balanced margins

VERY FINE. A RARE PAIR OF THE 1908 5-CENT VERTICAL COIL, SCOTT 317, CONTAINING A MINT NEVER-HINGED STAMP.

The 5c 1908 Coil stamps, which were stripped by hand, are almost always centered to one side. The example offered here, with balanced margins side-to-side and a Mint N.H. stamp, is a rarity for the issue.

With 1977 P.F. certificate as "o.g., genuine"

17,750
10,500
Back to Top
559
og
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 559, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)1c Blue Green, Coil (318), 1c Blue Green, Coil (318)1c Blue Green, Coil (318). Pair, gorgeous deep color, balanced margins

VERY FINE. A RARE PAIR OF THE ONE-CENT 1908 HORIZONTAL COIL.

Both stamps with Mekeel backstamp. With 1980 A.P.S. and 1994 P.F. certificates

15,000
6,000
Back to Top
560
og
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 560, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)2c Carmine, Coil (322), 2c Carmine, Coil (322)2c Carmine, Coil (322). Pair, h.r., brilliant color, well-balanced margins, couple minor perf separations

VERY FINE AND CHOICE PAIR OF THE RARE 2-CENT 1908 HORIZONTAL COIL.

Issued on July 31, 1908, and intended only to be used by private vending machine companies, Scott 322 is only known with the Die II widened line at lower left.

With 1996 P.F. certificate

17,500
8,000
Back to Top
561
nhbl
Sale Number 1096, Lot Number 561, 1906-08 Issue Imperforates and Coils (Scott 314A-322)2c Carmine, Ty. I (319), 2c Carmine, Ty. I (319)2c Carmine, Ty. I (319). Mint N.H. bottom imprint and plate no. 2252 block of six with narrow selvage, radiant color, choice centering, fresh and Extremely Fine

310
140
Back to Top
Copyright 2020. All rights reserved by Siegel Auction Galleries Inc. Information and images may be used with credit to Siegel Auction Galleries or siegelauctions.com subject to guidelines and restrictions.
Website Terms of Use and Privacy Policy