Sale 1024 — The Natalee Grace Collection of Used Stamps of the United States, Part One: 1847-1868 Issues

Sale Date — Thursday, 7 June, 2012

Category — 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)

Lot
Symbol
Photo/Description
Cat./Est. Value
Realized
17°
 
Sale 1024, Lot 17, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. I (5). Position 7R1E, huge margins including portion of adjoining stamp at bottom (Position 17R), just barely touched at left, rich color in the distinctive bright Plate 1 Early shade, proof-like impression, neat strike of blue "Richmond Va. Nov. 24" circular datestamp leaves every single design characteristic clearly visible

EXTREMELY FINE. QUITE PROBABLY THE FINEST OFF-COVER SINGLE OF SCOTT NUMBER 5 IN EXISTENCE, AND ONE OF ONLY A FEW SOUND EXAMPLES. POSITION 7R1E -- THE SEVENTH STAMP IN THE RIGHT PANE OF PLATE ONE EARLY -- IS THE ONLY ONE OF THE 1,000 POSITIONS USED TO PRINT IMPERFORATE ONE-CENT STAMPS THAT SHOWS THE COMPLETE DESIGN (TYPE I). ESPECIALLY DESIRABLE WITH THE BLUE RICHMOND CIRCULAR DATESTAMP. A MAGNIFICENT EXAMPLE OF THE RAREST AND MOST DESIRABLE CLASSIC IMPERFORATE UNITED STATES STAMP.

The published census compiled by Jerome S. Wagshal contains 90 unduplicated records of Scott 5. There has been one addition to the Wagshal census, and there are probably no more than ten examples existing outside of the census population. Therefore, the 1c 1851 Type I is the rarest of all United States stamps issued regularly prior to the 1868 Grills.

Because of the significance attached to the outer portions of the 1c 1851 design, rare types that have been carefully cut apart, so as not to impinge on any part of the design, are extremely desirable. The narrow spacing between stamps in the sheet and the users' indifference to the outlying ornamentation during separation are factors that contributed to the great rarity of four-margin copies. The example offered here comes from the "Warner strip" of Positions 7-9R1E, which was cut apart with a view towards preserving the margins of this stamp. Examples of Position 7R1E (Scott 5) with large right and bottom margins, where there was very little space between it and the adjoining stamps, are true rarities. In fact, using the census data, it is clear that this stamp is among the two or three finest sound examples known.

Wagshal Census No. 5-CAN-047. Ex Caspary, Twigg-Smith, Hinrichs and Scarsdale (where it realized $375,000 hammer). With 1976, 2001 and 2007 P.F. certificates.

E. 300,000-400,000
0
18
 
Sale 1024, Lot 18, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. Ib (5A). Position 6R1E, large part of top sheet margin, huge margins on other three sides, wonderful bright early shade and proof-like impression, blue Philadelphia circular datestamp cancel

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. A SPECTACULAR COMBINATION OF CONDITION, COLOR AND RARITY. POSITIONS 6R AND 8R FURNISHED THE BEST TYPE Ib EXAMPLES, SHOWING THE COMPLETE DESIGN AT TOP AND NEARLY COMPLETE DESIGN AT BOTTOM. THIS IS EASILY ONE OF THE FINEST EXAMPLES OF THIS TYPE IN EXISTENCE. A REMARKABLE STAMP IN EVERY RESPECT.

Type Ib was produced only as an imperforate stamp and does not have a perforated counterpart. Six positions on Plate 1 Early furnished stamps qualifying as Type Ib -- Positions 3-6R and 8-9R -- distinguished by the complete design at top and nearly complete design at bottom. When first entered on the plate, these six positions (as well as 7R1E) had the complete design at top and bottom. However, unlike 7R, small portions of the bottoms were burnished away. Positions 6R and 8R had less of the bottom erased than the other Type Ib positions, and for this reason they are more desirable examples of the type.

All Type Ib stamps are very scarce, and the two best examples (6R and 8R) are rare. These top-row positions usually have an ample top margin, but frequently the margins are close or cutting into the sides or bottom. A Type Ib with large margins all around is a great rarity, particularly in sound condition.

Ex Zoellner. With 1987 P.F. certificate for pair from which this single originates and 2009 P.F. certificate as single.

15,300
21,000
Back to Top
19
 
Sale 1024, Lot 19, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. Ia (6). Position 95R4, large margins all around including sheet margin at bottom and trace of adjoining stamp at top, perfectly-struck "Springfield Jul. 18" (1857) circular datestamp leaves design characteristics easily visible, deep Plate 4 color on bright fresh paper

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. AN OUTSTANDING EXAMPLE OF THE IMPERFORATE 1851 ONE-CENT TYPE Ia. A BEAUTIFUL STAMP IN EVERY RESPECT -- IT HAS BRIGHT PAPER, DEEP RICH COLOR, A PROOF-LIKE IMPRESSION, AND A BEAUTIFUL CANCELLATION WHICH ALLOWS THE TYPE CHARACTERISTICS TO BE CLEARLY SEEN. A STAMP FOR THE TRUE CONNOISSEUR.

Stamps printed from Plate 4 were issued in April, May and briefly in June 1857 before perforations were introduced. The relatively small number of imperforate Plate 4 stamps issued during this period explains the rarity and desirability of any of the imperforate stamp types produced from this plate (Ia, Ic, II, III and IIIa). The extremely rare Type Ia, showing the full design at bottom, was furnished only by 18 of the 200 subjects on Plate 4 (the remaining two bottom-row positions were sub-type Ic).

Perforated stamps were introduced in July 1857 (EDU for perforated stamps is July 26, 1857, and the EDU for perforated stamps from Plate 4 is Aug. 1). The rare imperforate Type Ia offered here was used during the last week before perforated stamps were introduced at post offices.

Ex Dr. Puliafito and offered to the market for the first time in over a decade. With 1996 P.F. and 2009 P.S.E. certificates (XF 90; SMQ $27,500.00).

13,000
21,000
Back to Top
20
 
Sale 1024, Lot 20, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. Ic (6b). Position 89R4, E Relief, huge and balanced margins all around, deep rich Plate 4 color and proof-like impression which shows every nuance of the design, neat strike of circular datestamp cancel

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. WITHOUT QUESTION THIS IS ONE OF THE FINEST EXAMPLES OF THE RARE 1851 ONE-CENT TYPE Ic IN EXISTENCE. THIS STAMP HAS EVERY QUALITY ONE COULD ASK FOR -- LARGE BALANCED MARGINS, BRIGHT PAPER, RICH COLOR AND A PERFECTLY-STRUCK CANCEL WHICH LEAVES THE DESIGN CHARACTERISTICS CLEARLY VISIBLE. A TRUE RARITY.

This variety is often confused for Scott 6, Type Ia, which is complete at bottom. However, this sub-type has the ball and plume at lower right slightly less complete. This variety has been widely recognized by experts for decades, but was only added to Scott Catalogue in 1993.

This stamp is far scarcer than its Scott Catalogue value would suggest, especially with four margins in sound condition. Power Search failed to find its equal. In fact, we have offered only seven unduplicated examples since 1997, two of which are on cover and one of which is in a pair with another type. It is likely that the paucity of copies trading hands has resulted in the Scott Catalogue value not being properly updated.

Ex Kharasch and Chapin. Illustrated in Volume I of Ashbrook's 1c book on p. 243. Illustrated in Brookman on p. 118. With 1971 and 2003 P.F. and 2009 P.S.E. certificates (XF-Superb 95; SMQ $11,000.00). This is the highest grade awarded to date and the only example to achieve this grade.

3,000
18,500
Back to Top
21
 
Sale 1024, Lot 21, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. II (7). Position 60R2, large to huge margins all around including huge right sheet margin with "nter, Casilear & Co. BANK NOTE E" imprint and plate no. 2, neat strike of 1857 year-dated town datestamp, deep rich color

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. A STUNNING 1851 IMPERFORATE ONE-CENT TYPE II WITH THE PLATE NUMBER FROM PLATE 2.

Collectors who want the finest or most unusual examples of the classic imperforate issues are often stymied by common stamps, such as Scott No. 7, because it is difficult to find one example that stands apart from the rest. One way is to find a copy showing parts of all surrounding stamps, which is usually "made" by cutting out a single from a large multiple. Another approach, which is more difficult, is to find the stamp from either a corner-margin position or with part of the imprint or plate number.

The rarity of sound, four-margin copies increases exponentially when restricted to corner-margin or imprint examples. Imprints are found along eight positions on the 1c 1851-57 plates (four at left and four at right), and there are four corners of the full plate of 200 (plus the interior gutter positions). Many stamps from those positions were trimmed close to the design. The plate number is found on only two positions, and the number is almost never encountered on surviving stamps.

Ex Col. Edward H. R. Green. With 2009 P.S.E. certificate

150
8,000
Back to Top
22
 
Sale 1024, Lot 22, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. III (8). Plate 4, C Relief, huge margins all around, showing wide breaks in outer lines at top and bottom (possibly 64R4), deep rich color and proof-like impression, lightly cancelled by town datestamp which leaves the entire design clearly visible

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. A STUNNING USED EXAMPLE OF THE 1851 IMPERFORATE ONE-CENT TYPE III. A MAGNIFICENT STAMP IN EVERY RESPECT -- THE MARGINS ARE HUGE, THE BREAKS ARE WIDE, THE CANCEL IS CLEAR BUT NOT HEAVY AND THE PAPER IS FRESH.

Type III is defined as having breaks in the outer lines at both top and bottom. Many Type III stamps have breaks that were created or enlarged by plate wear. Since the wear occurred over a period of time, the majority of stamps of this type (both unused and used) has small breaks in at least one line. This stamp is notable for its wide breaks at both top and bottom.

Ex Zoellner. With 1987 and 1998 P.F. and 2009 P.S.E. certificates (XF-Superb 95; SMQ $10,500.00). Only three have graded higher to date.

3,000
7,000
Back to Top
23
 
Sale 1024, Lot 23, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. III (8). Position 70R4, huge margins all around including right sheet margin and top portion of imprint ("Toppan Carpent"), wide break at bottom and substantial break at top, huge margins, rich color

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. A STUNNING JUMBO USED EXAMPLE OF THE 1851 ONE-CENT TYPE III. THIS TYPE IS EXTREMELY RARE WITH THE IMPRINT. THIS IS THE ONLY SOUND EXAMPLE OF TYPE III SHOWING THE IMPRINT WE HAVE OFFERED SINCE KEEPING COMPUTERIZED RECORDS. APART FROM THE IMPRINT, THIS IS ALSO ONE OF THE FINEST TYPE III STAMPS IN EXISTENCE, BY VIRTUE OF ITS HUGE BALANCED MARGINS, FACE-FREE CANCEL AND WONDERFUL COLOR AND IMPRESSION.

The Neinken book states, "Stamps from Plate 4 showing part of the imprint are very rare." Looking at the layout of Plate 4 (Neinken book, page 263), the imprint position types are as follows: left pane 31/41L Type IIIa, 51L Type IIIa-III, 61L Type III; right pane 40R Type III, 50/60R Type IIIa, 70R Type III. Therefore, only Positions 61L, 40R and 70R4 are Type III imprint positions (51L is a "swing" position with a smaller break).

Ex Vogel. With 2011 P.F. certificate as a pair with Type IIIa.

3,000
6,750
Back to Top
24
 
Sale 1024, Lot 24, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. III, Position 99R2 (8). Huge margins to full, bright color, bold strike of New York circular datestamp which leaves the design characteristics -- wide breaks at top and bottom and distinct double transfer at right -- clearly visible

EXTREMELY FINE. A BEAUTIFUL AND RARE SOUND FOUR-MARGIN EXAMPLE OF THE 1851 IMPERFORATE ONE-CENT TYPE III FROM POSITION 99R2. THIS POSITION PRODUCED THE BEST EXAMPLE OF TYPE III, WITH THE WIDEST BREAKS AT TOP AND BOTTOM.

Type III is defined by breaks in the outer lines at both top and bottom. Many Type III stamps have breaks that were created or enlarged by plate wear. Since the wear occurred over a period of time, a majority of stamps of this type (both unused and used) has small breaks in at least one line. The most notable exception is Position 99R2. According to the Neinken book, "The 99R2 stamp is a fresh entry, that was short transferred both at top and bottom, over an original entry that had been erased... The reason that 99R2 is the finest example of Type III is because of its very short transfer at top and at bottom, giving us the wide breaks in these lines." (p. 184).

A review using Power Search plus a search of older auction catalogues reveals that this position is extremely difficult to find with four margins and in sound condition.

Ex Floyd. With 1988 and 2001 P.F. certificates

12,500
10,000
Back to Top
25
 
Sale 1024, Lot 25, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IIIa (8A). Position 41L4, huge margins to full including part of adjoining stamps at top and bottom, "penter, Casilier & Co., BANK NOTE E" portion of imprint at left, deep rich color and proof-like impression, neat strike of 7-bar grid cancel, tiny thin spot at top by "O" of "Postage"

EXTREMELY FINE APPEARANCE. ONE OF THE FEW EXAMPLES KNOWN OF THE ONE-CENT 1851 IMPERFORATE FROM PLATE 4 SHOWING ANY PART OF THE IMPRINT.

The Neinken book states "Stamps from Plate 4 showing part of the imprint are rare." A review with Power Search shows we have offered three unused and three used since keeping computerized records. This is by far the finest of the used copies.

Ex Vogel. With 2011 P.F. certificate.

1,100
900
Back to Top
26
 
Sale 1024, Lot 26, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IIIa (8A). Huge margins all around including parts of adjoining stamps at sides, beautiful bright Plate 1 Early color, wide break at top, light strike of "Laurel Ind. Nov. 24" circular datestamp

EXTREMELY FINE. A SUPERB USED EXAMPLE OF THE 1851 IMPERFORATE ONE-CENT TYPE IIIA FROM PLATE ONE EARLY.

Type IIIa is defined as having a break in outer lines at either top or bottom. The example offered here, which clearly shows the bottom line complete and top line with wide break, is a superb example of the type.

Ex Drucker and Scarsdale. With 1983 and 2002 P.F. certificates.

1,100
1,400
Back to Top
27
 
Sale 1024, Lot 27, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IV (9). Position 70R1L, recut once at top and bottom, huge margins to clear including right sheet margin with "Toppan, Carpen" portion of imprint, deep rich color, neat strike of "Pittsburgh Pa. Jun. 15" circular datestamp, Very Fine and choice, desirable and scarce with the part imprint, we have offered only two sound four-margin used examples with the imprint since keeping computerized records, ex Vogel, with 2011 P.F. certificate as pair

110
1,700
Back to Top
28
 
Sale 1024, Lot 28, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IV (9). Position 1R1L with top left inter-pane centerline margin, large to huge margins other sides, rich color on nicely blued paper, neat strike of red circular datestamp, fresh and Extremely Fine, a beautiful stamp, with 2009 P.F. certificate

140
450
Back to Top
29
 
Sale 1024, Lot 29, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IV (9). Position 97L1L, major double transfer which is especially noticeable at bottom, enormous margins all around including wide sheet margin at bottom and part of adjoining stamps on three sides, rich color, bold strike of grid cancel

EXTREMELY FINE GEM. A MAGNIFICENT USED EXAMPLE OF THE ONE-CENT IMPERFORATE TYPE IV FROM POSITION 97L1L, WITH MAJOR DOUBLE TRANSFER AT BOTTOM. A SUPERB STAMP IN EVERY RESPECT.

Double and triple transfers occur when a plate is made or reconditioned. Either an earlier entry from the transfer roll is insufficiently burnished out, or the subsequent re-entry is slightly misaligned, leaving incised lines on the plate that transfer ink to the printed impression. Plate 1 Late, which was reconditioned, has a total of 51 double transfers, but Neinken specifically identified sixteen he considered "so pronounced they are outstanding." Position 97L is one of these (see Neinken book, page 120).

Ex Scarsdale. With 2002 P.F. certificate

120
850
Back to Top
30
 
Sale 1024, Lot 30, 1c 1851-56 Issue (Scott 5-9)1c Blue, Ty. IV, Printed on Both Sides (9a). The back has an impression of the top part of the design printed inverted relative to the normal impression on the other side, normal side with large margins to just touched with part of adjoining stamps at top and left, rich color, neat strike of large Boston "Paid" grid, light corner crease at top right

VERY FINE. THE ONLY RECORDED EXAMPLE OF THE ONE-CENT 1851 ISSUE PRINTED ON BOTH SIDES. A PHENOMENAL RARITY.

Engraved stamps printed on both sides usually have a poor impression on one side and a second, complete impression on the other. They probably occurred when a sheet was printed without proper moistening, which prevented the paper from picking up the ink in the recessed lines of the engraved plate. If the sheet was turned 180 degrees before being put on the press a second time, the two impressions will be inverted in relation to each other.

Our list of printed-on-both-sides stamps is included as an appendix to this catalogue. The variety is known on the three denominations issued in 1851 -- 1c, 3c and 12c -- but not on the imperforate stamps issued in 1855 (10c) and 1856 (5c). This is the only recorded example of the one-cent 1851 design printed on both sides.

Ex Wagshal. With 1977 P.F. certificate.

50,000
42,500
Back to Top